Why America's Pastime Is Losing Its Identity

On a May 28, 2006 Barry Bonds succeeded inmarketing to black youth, who rarely ever go to
hitting his 715th home run to pass Babe Ruth'sMLB games. And making the National Football
homerun record and now second to Hank Aaron'sLeague (NFL) is far more attractive than an
Major League Baseball (MLB) all-time home runarduous and lengthy learning process on the way
record of 755, it is representative in a number ofto earning a MLB contract. Both the NBA and the
ways of the present state of MLB. Specifically,NFL although now require at least a year of
the state of the game's future in thecollege play, are a fast track on the way to fast
African-American community comes to mind. Andbucks for those lucky enough to make it. Still, the
it might be an appropriate time to reexamine thefamily fabric not only in the inner city, but more
decline of participation of the black athlete inpronounced there, has destroyed the learning
baseball, which is a far more multi-facetedcurve necessary to build a baseball following.
problem than commonly expressed.Baseball requires a father or father figure such as
While there is a dearth of interest among younga youth leader or mentor to have an impact
boys and teenagers in the black communityupon, what used to be considered the National
participating in organized baseball, the reasonsPastime, the inner-city child. And if they are not
most often provided are shortsighted and oftenhooked by age 13 or 14, it's hard to get them
too easy to come by. Without an honestinterested later.
discourse between the leaders of the blackRequisite hand-eye coordination skills do not come
communities throughout the United States, as wellto children naturally and must be learned, unlike
as some candor coming from the offices of MLB,the immediate impact of shooting a basketball or
what seems an insurmountable problem to attractrunning with a football. It takes patience and
blacks to baseball, will forever remain.fortitude for those skills that must be nurtured.
And although it is simply too easy to blame anyHistorically, such nurturers were fathers. But also
one entity for all of the fall-off of black players inabsent today is the presence of present MLB
baseball, the primary beneficiary, of ignoringplayers who do not involve themselves with the
players from the U.S. including white players,community like Hall of Famers, Hank Aaron, Willie
remains MLB. And it must be held accountable,Mays, Frank Robinson and Reggie Jackson did. The
regardless of myriad cultural reasons attributed toblack MLB player today must step up even more
children's lack of interest in baseball, predominantlyso, especially because of the lack of male role
in the inner city neighborhoods, for its lack ofmodels in the black community.
investment in them.The dissolution of the once three-sport player has
On February 28, 2006, MLB opened its first Urbanalso added to the demise of baseball in the inner
Youth Academy in the U.S. At a cost of $3 millioncity. Many public schools only field a football team
which took three years to complete, with theor basketball team and have dropped baseball
idea shopped around for six, MLB Commissioneraltogether. Intramural programs, the victim of
Bud Selig clucked, "This is the first of what I hopebudget cuts, only heightens the chances that
is a series of academies all over America." Theblack youth will be absorbed into gangs, due to
facility is located at the campus of Comptonlack of organized programs for them.
Community College on 10 acres of land inAnd for college baseball players, scouting is limited
Compton, CA, south of Los Angeles. It includesand even more so for the black baseball athlete
two regulation size baseball diamonds, a youthwho rarely competes in baseball in college due to
field and one for girl's softball and a 12,000 squarethe small scholarships awarded for baseball. Even
foot clubhouse with locker room, weight roomHoward University has dropped its baseball
and other training facilities. It is expected to be aprogram, which one would think is a no-brainer for
prototype for other U.S. facilities, through thethe development of African American baseball
Urban Youth Initiative, which will serve not only asplayers, given its vast appreciation of black
a catalyst for reviving baseball but a place forhistory. The National Collegiate Athletic Association
inner-city youth to enjoy each summer and afteronly allows for 11.7 baseball scholarships at any
school.given time for a team of 30 players on a roster.
Starting in June 2006, 125 children each day areFull scholarships are rare. Football, however, is
expected to participate and to be given instructionallowed up to 85 scholarships and basketball gets
by professional level coaches on playing the game.13 for a roster half the size of baseball's. Both
The monetary investment however was notprograms are provided far more full scholarships.
solely supplied by MLB. $70,000.00 was collectivelyFrank Robinson, now 70, and presently the
donated by Enos Cabell, Jr. and Tim Purpura, GMManager of the Washington Nationals after holding
of the Houston Astros for batting cages andseveral positions within MLB, became part of the
$500,000.00 was donated by L.A.'s Anaheimfirst generation of great black players who
Angels. Access to classrooms and computers arefollowed Jackie Robinson's breaking the color
being made available by Compton Communitybarrier in 1947. And Frank Robinson holds today's
College. Compton was picked primarily as soplayers accountable. "People don't see minorities
many African-Americans from MLB's past aroseattached to the community or going home and
from Compton, but also because the collegegiving something back. Now the stars and the top
donated a number of its facilities. It takes onplayers, they hide. They don't go into the
average three years to build a Major Leaguecommunity. They don't go back into the inner city
stadium. It is stunning how long it took to put inor where their roots were. Baseball is now third,
four ball fields and a clubhouse with so littlemaybe fourth in the [inner-city] household."
financial investment from MLB and whose ideaYet, the baseball draft instilled in 1965, with
largely came to the Commissioner's Office as astricter age limits, combined with MLB's vastly
grass roots effort.increased development in Latin America over the
In 1989, former Major League player, John Young,past 20 years, remain the biggest impediments,
developed a program called RBI or Revivingalong with the lack of MLB's moral will, in increasing
Baseball in Inner Cities in South Central Losthe African-American presence in MLB. Much like
Angeles for children ages 12-18. In 1991, MLB gotthe ill-fated acceptance of the offshoring of U.S.
involved and assumed its administration. MLB thenmanufacturing jobs by U.S. multi-national
teamed with the Sporting Goods Manufacturingcorporations, MLB has enjoyed the same
Association from 1993-1996 in providing grants tomisguided regime, regardless if it ultimately hurts
various cities demonstrating financial need. Afterthe American athlete.
five years, Young went national and by 1997 RBICommissioner Selig stated after the 2005 season
collaborated with various chapters of the Boysthat gate receipts, merchandising revenue, team
& Girls Clubs of America. However, MLB andrevenue- sharing and acquired broadcast rights
its individual teams have only provided $15 millionrevenue were at all-time highs in MLB. He likes the
for RBI since 1991.public to know that, given his abysmal
The RBI program now includes both boys andmanagement in other areas such allowing steroids
girls and its objective is to also include nurturingin baseball over the years, the 1994 strike, the
children's interest in school along with baseball ashandling of the sale of the Montreal Expos,
the main component. It claims that it has helpedincluding his lack of involvement with the black
more than 150,000 children in more than 200community. However, while baseball enjoys such
cities worldwide play baseball. And its Quick"good times," like its multi-national counterparts,
SMART! Program addresses the issues of alcohol,MLB does not reinvest in the U.S.
tobacco and other harmful drugs with city youth.Much like cheap labor overseas appears to be a
Says Roberto Clemente, Jr., who founded the RBIrequired component of U.S. industry, similarly the
program in Pittsburgh, "RBI keeps kids out ofbenefits of signing and investing in baseball players
trouble and off the streets, while at the samehas been relegated to Latin American players and
time teaching them to stay in school. Themore recently in Asia, where the rules of the U.S.
educational components help them realize theirdo not apply. So instead, MLB has found new
potential and worth in receiving college scholarshipsways to circumvent its problems by merely
based not only on athletics, but academics." Butskipping over U.S. players. And while the
one can question the program's expansionAfrican-American community has seen the
worldwide before the job is done in the U.S.starkest decline in participation, the white
"Campos Las Palmas has set the standard forcommunity is also losing ground to foreign players.
what a baseball academy should be and we'reMore than 40% of major and minor league
extremely proud of the work done here, not onlyplayers are born outside of the U.S., with nearly
on the field, but in the community as well." No, this30% comprising the major leagues. It is predicted
is not another baseball academy planned for thethat by 2007 over 50% of all major and minor
U.S. but a quote from Frank McCourt, owner ofleague players will be Latin Americans.
the Los Angeles Dodgers, upon his visit to thePrior to 1965, teams could contract with any high
Dodger's Dominican Republic baseball complex, inschool graduate that scouts identified. Since it was
celebrating its 20th year anniversary, earlier inbelieved that this advantaged only the wealthier
2006. And while no one can find fault with theteams, MLB imposed the draft. U.S. citizens could
individual efforts of the RBI program nor with theno longer be signed immediately, starting the cycle
idea of Urban Youth Academies in the U.S., it isof lack of development investment by particular
necessary to contrast those programs with overclubs. Along with supposedly eliminating the
the $60 million dollars each year which MLB and itsexploitation of underage players, the age
individual teams pour into Latin American countriesrestrictions followed. However, a player can be
for player development.signed to a MLB contract at age 16 in Latin
Most MLB teams have more than one such facilityAmerica with the clubs spending several years
in Latin America with the most located in thedeveloping those players far earlier. By the time a
Dominican Republic, followed by Venezuela. WhenU.S. player reaches 18 or 21 if they are in college,
Camp Las Palmas opened in the 1987 season, itthey are years behind Latin American players.
was the first facility of its kind and became theSecondly, the contracts offered the Latin
universal prototype for all MLB teams in LatinAmerican undeveloped players are far less than
America. It sits on 75 acres of land, equipped withthose offered drafted U.S. prospects. And prior to
two full and two half baseball fields, a dining room,1984 there was no age limit on signing Latin
kitchen, recreation room and two two-storyAmerican players who were signed as young as
dormitories accommodating 100 players. In12 or 14.
addition, it provides lessons in adapting toSince developing players is a big expense, MLB
American culture, classes in English, and nutritionalsimply went after the "cheap and unregulated
counseling.labor." Sound familiar? And for foreign and U.S.
Players stay up to 30 days at a time and can beplayers of similar talent levels the expected
signed at age 16 unlike players in the U.S. whererecompense for U.S. players is much lower given
players must at least complete high school or bethe lack of property rights in developing him and
18 years of age. If they are enrolled in college,what is expected to be a shorter career. If it is a
U.S. players must wait until the age of 21 to bechoice between two players of equal talent in the
signed. But then they go into the draft, whichU.S. or Latin America, the MLB club invariably
clubs claim deters them from investing in anychooses the foreign or Latin American player.
development of U.S. players, as another club couldWhile white players who are affluent or have a
end up as the beneficiary of such efforts. Also,family willing to invest resources to have their
Latin America does not face competition fromsons join available teams outside the inner city,
the sports of basketball and football as baseballthe road still remains a gamble due to the outright
does in the U.S., therefore giving MLB many morescouting delays of Americans, given the
prospects to choose from.preference of the cheaper talent. Unless a draft
It is crucial to understand that offshoring of Latinchoice is truly bankable, the chances of that
American baseball players is arguably directlyprospect succeeding are contingent upon his
proportional to the loss of African Americansformer training either from college or paid for
being developed in MLB. Black players were atopportunities from family. And U.S. baseball players
their peak of their composition in MLB in the latedo not have the benefit of competing at
'70's and early '80's or roughly 27% of all players.academies like those in Latin America, often run
Today that total hovers around 10%. However, itlike baseball boarding schools with seemingly
is the combination of other factors which makeunlimited budgets.
the Latin American factor even more decimatingIn conclusion, much like the U.S. watches its
to the black athlete's chances of ever making itindustries and institutions being sold bit by bit to
to the Major Leagues.foreign entities, it will take the will of the
Ideologies include the increased incarceration ofcommunity, not just the black community or the
young black males, the lack of positive rolewhite community, but the American community,
models and the lack of two parent families asto fight for our young people and to show them
contributing factors. They, however, cannotthat America is worth fighting for. We can no
necessarily be declared the primary determinantslonger afford to isolate ourselves from each other
of the lack of blacks' participation in baseball. It isregardless of our color or ethnicity. For this fight is
argued that expense is a factor, as it supposedlyfar more than the one between basketball and
takes $100,000.00 to build a baseball field and thatbaseball. It is symbolic of the erosion of that
even if there are baseball fields available,which once identified America and was a staple of
maintenance costs are necessary too. But urbanthe family and by extension our neighborhoods.
and rural African-Americans played baseball onAnd contrary to popular belief, the hijacking of
sandlots and played street stickball forAmerica's National Pastime is not unimportant, but
generations, long before pristine $100,000.00 fieldsis indicative of a dangerous trend in the U.S. And
were considered a prerequisite to playing baseball.we owe it to ourselves as Americans to not only
Others argue that the National Basketballsave our children in the process but in turn to
Association (NBA) has done a far better job atsave our country.