Shirley Sherrod - Who's to Blame?

Over the past several days, the story of Shirleybegan with the Spooner's as she moved past her
Sherrod, formally the Georgia State Director ofinitial reaction to come to their aid. In fact, the
Rural Development, has monopolized the news,Spooner's appeared on national TV to refute the
eclipsing the Gulf oil spill, the long-awaited passingclaims made against Sherrod and thanked her for
of HR 4213 extending emergency unemploymentsaving their farm, now 25 years ago.
benefits, and the recent heating up of the conflictAs the truth of Sherrod's speech and the entire
in Afghanistan.40 minute speech was made available to the
Sherrod deserves an apology says the Americanpublic, Vilsack extended Sherrod a public apology.
people, as a 2-minute clip vilifying her was foundShe was also offered a position with the Civil
to be taken out of context, pulled from aRights office of outreach, to which Sherrod states
40-minute speech she presented at a NAACPshe needs time to consider. Vilsack's apology has
banquet earlier this year. At the onset it appearedallowed the Obama administration to distance
that Sherrod was indeed a racist. Fox News, thethemselves from the heated debate. Yet,
White House, NAACP, and Sherrod's boss,Sherrod is on record as having said on the day of
Secretary of Agriculture Tom Vilsack, allher dismissal, Cheryl Cook, USDA Deputy Under
reportedly weighed in with their opinion and sheSecretary, called Sherrod three times as Sharrod
was summarily fired from her position.was enroute to her office, requesting her
During the 2-minute clip, Sherrod discussed herwhereabouts. During the third and final call, Cook
handling of a family, the Spooner's, who had comestated the controversy over Sherrod's speech
to her in an attempt to save their farm;was to be highlighted on Glenn Beck that evening,
"What he didn't know while he was taking all thatand why the White House was requesting her
time trying to show me he was superior to meresignation. Sherrod complied, pulling to the side of
was, I was trying to decide just how much help Ithe road to resign her position over her cell phone.
was going to give him. I was struggling with theVilsack, the NAACP and the White House are not
fact that so many black people had lost theirthe only ones in the hot seat: It appears that Fox
farmland, and here I was faced with having toNews has received a one-two punch by CNN for
help a white person save their land.prematurely attacking Sherrod without practicing
So I didn't give him the full force of what I coulddue diligence by verifying the story.
do. I did enough, so that when he...I assumed theSo who is the guilty party? Is it the White House,
Department of Agriculture had sent him to me,the NAACP, the media, a premature, knee-jerk
either that or the Georgia Department ofreaction by Vilsack, or all the above? We may
Agriculture, and he needed to go back and reportnever know. This writer suspects the intense,
that I did try to help him."over-the-top reaction to Sherrod's speech before
However, listening to the full context of heran honest investigation of the facts, no matter
40-minute speech, one finds a much differentthe perpetrator, is the direct result of the wound
message--one in which Sherrod discusses with herof racism continually being ripped open by the
audience how she was able to move past herpress, thus stirring the pot of racial unrest.
predigest, even though her fathers murder thatIf anything positive can be culled from this
occurred when she was growing up was found todebacle, it is that it has shown a light of reason on
be racially motivated. The crux of Sherrod'sthe issue. Many on the left, the right, and those
speech to the NAACP that day was to encouragein-between have had an opportunity to examine
others to move past racism and instead seekthe issue and to learn from it and consider
compassion for the poor, no matter their color.ourselves lucky to have been introduced to a
Her journey, Sherrod shared with her audience,woman of Shirley Sherrod's character.