Review: Russell Shorto's "The Island At The Center Of The World"

Up to now the preponderant view held by manyby the more progressive thinking of some of
historians is that Dutch contribution to AmericanEurope's most enlightened thinkers as Descartes,
history and particularly to that of New York hasGrotius, and Spinoza. It is the freedoms espoused
been one of irrelevancy. As we no doubt realize,by these thinkers that van der Donck believed in.
the winners write history, and unfortunately,Eventually, they would find root in the Dutch
whatever the losers may have contributed, itcolony, ultimately becoming the foundation of
seems to be lost or forgotten in the shuffle.many of the democratic principles forming the
Fortunately, during the past thirty years andbasis of the American cultural, economic and
thanks to the translation of many Dutch recordssociological psyche. On the other hand,
that have been recently discovered pertaining toStuyvesant, who lacked the same formal
the early colony of New Netherlands, a differenteducation as van der Donck, was stuck in his old
picture has emerged. It is this new perspectivetyrannical concepts and narrow- minded
that author Russell Shorto has vividly and brilliantlyprejudices, which effect was to stifle the
captured in his latest gem of a book entitled, Theaspirations of the inhabitants of the Dutch colony.
Island at the Center of the World.It is fortunate for the USA that the theories and
Shorto devotes considerable ink in defending hisbeliefs of van der Donck won out.
thesis that the success of Manhattan as aAs a side note and to indicate the extent of the
commercial center, or New York, as it wasDutch influence on American culture, Shorto also
renamed after the British takeover, did not beginreveals such interesting tidbits as what settlers
with the English but rather had very deep roots inemigrating to the Dutch colony would bring along
the early Dutch community. It was in fact in thewith them, the derivation of words such as
late 1640s that the city of New Amsterdamcookies, cole slaw and Santa Claus, that can all
under Dutch rule began its rise to become Northtrace their roots to the Dutch colony of New
American's shipping hub. Furthermore, one of theNetherlands. We also have an overview and some
key actors who played a pivotal role in thefascinating insights as to what actually transpired
community was, up to now, a long forgottenbetween the Dutch and the English at the time
visionary, Adriaen van der Donck, who oftenthe latter took possession of New Nederland.
found himself, locked in a power- struggle withShorto's animated characterizations of individuals
Peter Stuyvesant. The latter has always beenand events is consistently enlightening entertaining,
more recognizable than the former, particularlyinformative and balanced, all of which make for a
due to the fact that it was he who surrenderedpowerful analysis of events that have had an
the Dutch colony to the British.unbelievable influence on American culture, political
What was very little publicized up to now wasand economic institutions.
that van der Donck had being heavily influenced